Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kelly Brother's avatar

Excellent. Especially the closing paragraphs.

One point: Your dismissal of Ryan Poe’s work seems like a hand wave:

“Other elaborate historical revisions, like Richard Poe’s How the British Invented Communism (And Blamed It on the Jews), are equally unconvincing.”

I read Poe’s book and found it plausible and intriguing; especially the British role in the FR. And subsequent color revolutions. Historian Matthew Ehret takes a similar point of view. Can you point me to a deeper critique of Poe’s work that supports your interpretation?

Expand full comment
CP's avatar

Very enjoyable. I especially enjoyed the cover of writers like Barruel and Webster. I’d like to suggest that the FR was the first political instance of the mutability of human nature (via Locke and Helvétius) expressed as régénération. This has served as an excuse for mass slaughter ever since: no price is too high for the elevation to a new type of human being.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts